User login

FRT: not entirely random

Submitted by Rodney Herring on Fri, 2006-06-02 13:08.

Posted in | | Rodney Herring's blog | add new comment | printer friendly version »

The not entirely random part of this is that I started with song 1 intentionally. I totally love this new Dixie Chicks album.

  1. 'The Long Way Around,' Dixie Chicks
  2. 'Dear Sarah Shu,' John Vanderslice
  3. 'Mary of the Wild Moor,' Johnny Cash
  4. 'Big Brown Eyes,' Old 97's
  5. 'C'mere,' Interpol
  6. 'Time,' Tom Waits
  7. 'Angela,' John Vanderslice (seriously)
  8. 'Somedays I See the Point,' Billy Bragg
  9. 'Losing Hope,' Jack Johnson
  10. 'Goodbye Is All We Have,' Alison Krauss
Fri, 2006-06-02 14:31

I really enjoy the first

Scott Eric Kaufman (not verified) Says:

I really enjoy the first four songs--although "Not Ready to Make Nice" isn't holding up to repetition--but then there's the silly country thumper about Lubbock and some forgettable stuff.

What's up with the "(seriously)" after "Angela"? That's a damn fine song. (Also, any help you can provide unlocking the rest of Cellar Door would be greatly appreciated.)

Fri, 2006-06-02 15:21

Yes, no, and I have no idea

Rodney Herring Says:

Oh, "Angela" is an incredible song; it's held the status of "new favorite song of all time" for the past couple of months--a label only ever so gradually wearing off. The "seriously" is about how my iPod fucks with me, as in, "Seriously, two John Vanderslice songs in the first 10 of the day?" [iPod answers: "seriously...and you like it."] But here's a question for you Scott: is "Angela" a song about the terrific sadness of freedom being joined with loss or about the speaker's terrible arrogance?

I don't quite agree on "Not Ready to Make Nice," though. It's holding up for me. There's something about how the "you think" is slipped in so subtly in the chorus, as though to say "I can't bring myself to do what it is (you think) I should," as in this anger's eating me up, but goddamnit I've turned the corner, and I'm gonna embrace it. And hence: whether or not "it's too late to make it right," "I probably wouldn't if I could"! For me, this bare hatred is beautiful, not because it's bitter or debilitating, but rather the opposite: one realizes herein that one can't "make it right" with the Right.

Now, on Cellar Door and all hyper allusive songs (such as perhaps my favorite Bob Dylan song, Desolation Road), I'm basically paralyzed with questions. It's like a puzzle I'm supposed to be able to figure out, but there are just too many variables. Even when we're told of "All these people that you mention," "I had to rearrange their faces / And give them all another name," I'm left thinking there are all these damn characters with whom we can't quite match a name or a face. So how is this other than just an epistemological nightmare? (Which is okay: I need a regular step back from certitude.)